Condiments, Dips & Spreads

"It's like they've done something to the lining of my stomach," describes a less than appreciative Matt Damon. "Oh my God, now it's really burning" shouts a confused and afraid David Harbour from the Hot One stage. Don't let the glowing impressions fool...

In the heart of the misty Caribbean Sea lies a mysterious land shrouded in legend, Ghost Island. Ghost Island is known for producing some of the most mouthwatering peppers on Earth. It's said that the soil there is kissed by the sun and tempered by the...

True to its name, this sauce takes heat-rich habanero chiles to a foundation of real sour cherries for a combination of fruity sweetness and unmistakable fire. Cherry Bomb has taken home over 20 trophies since its debut in 2012.From farm to bottleTart...

Get Thai-inspired brightness in a bottle! Fresh tastes of coconut, basil, lemongrass and lime come together to create this earthy and invigorating experience. Splash Down combines aromatic flavors that leave your tastebuds feeling refreshed and gratified...

A layered flavor experience, each drop of Cosmic Dumpling invites you to explore the balance between spicy, smoky, tangy, and savory notes.From farm to bottleTake-out repair kit flavorAward-winning heatAll-natural flavorVeganGluten freeDairy freeKarma...

One of the founding members of the Karma Sauce family, Bad Karma is your Swiss army knife in a bottle. Crafted with fresh Finger Lakes ingredients, this versatile sauce fuses bold flavors with just the right amount of heat to elevate your meals without...

Have you ever experienced a bite of perfect pineapple? Huhu Piña captures that moment of juicy, tropical bliss and packs it into every bottle. Imagine sunshine on a beach, a hint of the ocean breeze, the vibrant sweetness of freshly sliced...

With a huge following, Sweet Maple Mustard has a smooth texture and is just the right amount of sweet. It's a little thinner and can poured - so easy to added to your favorite recipe!Sweet and deliciousIdeal as sandwich condiment or pretzel dipMix into...

With a huge following, Sweet Maple Horseradish Mustard has a slight kick, but not too strong, and the mustard seed is left whole for a great texture.Sweet and savoryIdeal as sandwich condiment or pretzel dipMix into homemade salad dressingSpread on...

This lovely blend of Eden Specialty Ciders Peak Bloom cider and maple wood smoked Vermont onions is made with 100% Vermont grown apples and is perfection on a turkey sandwich.2025 World-Wide Mustard Competition, Best Whole Seed Mustard - Gold Medal...

The folks at Butterfly Bakery smoke sweet Vermont onions over maple wood and blend them up with red jalapenos to create this incredibly well balanced hot sauce. This medium hot sauce was a hit on Season 7 of Hot Ones and has been their best seller ever...

Heady Topper IPA really shines in this fabulous beer mustard.Farm to fork foodWhole seed mustardGreat for sausages, charcuterie, salad dressing, sandwiches, veggie dip, marinadesContains 47 servings per jarNet weight: 8 oz.Made in VermontIngredients:...

Sugar maple sap is gathered in Vermont sugar shacks in the spring, while the snow crunches underfoot. The sap is boiled down into maple syrup that the folks at Butterfly Bakery blend with Vermont red jalapenos and garlic scapes to create this tantalizing...

Heady Topper IPA, one of the world's best beers, is an intensely hoppy beer that makes for a lively dance with green Vermont jalapenos. This is a Use It Everywhere medium hot, craft beer hot sauce that will deliver you right up to hop heaven...

Maple wood smoked onions give this Smoked Onion Salsa a round, lightly sweet and lightly smoky flavor that perfectly compliments the locally grown tomatoes cooked down into this spectacular salsa.Farm to fork foodSweet and smoky flavorNet weight: 11 oz...

Butterfly Bakery made this spicy pickle mustard in collaboration with the musical awesomeness that is Guster. This is a garlic, dill, jalapeno and cucumber mustard that is fabulous on sausage, burgers and pretzels.Farm to fork foodWhole seed mustardGreat...

Butterfly Bakery made the first batch of this medium heat green salsa with green garlic that they pulled themselves on a farm work day at Honey Field Farm in Norwich Vermont. The lighter, sweeter flavor of the green garlic complements the tomatillos and...

A Vermont tradition, Pure Vermont Maple Syrup give a subtle sweetness to this coarse mustard. Add this iconic flavor to your cheese board, charcuterie board, and your favorite salad dressing recipe. Or turn your everyday grilled cheese, ham or roast beef...

Vermont Maple Horseradish Mustard has is it all the irresistible sweetness of pure Vermont maple syrup, with the added zip of horseradish.Pairs well with rich cheeses and meatsAdds a bit of sweetness and zing to sandwiches and sausagesNet weight: 8 oz...

Dedicated to horseradish lovers everywhere, this assertive mustard is excellent with meats, cheeses, and seafood.Adds zing to your favorite vinaigretteDelicious with meats, cheeses, and a variety of seafoodNet weight: 8 oz.Handmade in Vermont